Skip to main content
  • login
  • contact
  • language
    • English
    • Français
    • Español
    • Português
    • Deutsch
    • Italia
    • 简体中文
    • 日本語
  • search
X
    GEP Logo GEP Logo
    • Company  
        • About Us 
        • Culture 
        • Careers 
        • Contact Us 
        • AI-First at GEP
        • Sustainability at GEP

        About Us

        • Leadership
        • Customers
        • Partners
        • News
        • GEP in the News
        • Events
        • Mission & Vision
        • Awards & Recognition
        • Contact Us

        GEP Is a Leader in the 2025 Gartner® Magic Quadrant™ for Source-to-Pay Suites

        Read More
        A Procurement Software Platforms Leader — 4 Years Running

        Tariff Resource Center: Strategies and Action Plans 

        Read More

        Culture

        • Diversity
        • GEP Cares
        • GEP Core Values
        • Women at GEP
        A Procurement Software Platforms Leader — 4 Years Running

        GEP & Xylem Unite to Bring Clean Water to 1,800 in Maharashtra

        Mapping & Reducing Scope 3 Emissions: A Quickstart Guide for Procurement Pros

        GEP & Akshaya Patra: Partnering to Deliver 4 Billion Meals and Fight Hunger Worldwide

        Careers

        • Explore Global Careers Opportunties
        • North American
        • Europe
        • India
        • Latin America
        • Asia-Pacific
        • Join Us
        • GEP Per Se
        • Campus Connect
        TOP EMPLOYER 2025 - USA
        TOP EMPLOYER 2025 - UK
        TOP EMPLOYER 2025 - INDIA
        TOP EMPLOYER 2025 - Costa Rica

        Contact Us

        • Ask Us
        • Request for Proposal
        • Schedule a Demo
        • Share Feeback
        GEP - AMERICA

        GEP in the Americas

        GEP - EUROPE

        GEP in Europe

        GEP - ASIA

        GEP in Asia

        GEP - AFRICA

        GEP in Africa 

        GEP - Middle East

        GEP in the Middle East

        AI-First at GEP

        Sustainability at GEP

    • Solutions  
        • Software 
          • GEP SMART  
          • GEP NEXXE  
          • GEP FINA  
          • GEP QUANTUM  
          • GEP GREEN
        • Strategy 
          • Procurement Consulting  
          • Supply Chain Consulting  
        • Managed Services 
          • Procurement Outsourcing  
          • Supply Chain Outsourcing  

        Software

        GEP SMART

        • Procurement Software
        • Direct Procurement Software
        • Indirect Procurement Software
        • Midsize & High Growth Enterprises

        GEP NEXXE

        • AI-First Supply Chain Management 
        • Supply Chain Visibility and Execution 
        • Supply Chain Planning 
        • Supply Chain Collaboration  

        GEP FINA

        GEP GREEN

        GEP QUANTUM

         

        GEP SMART

        • Procurement Software
        • Direct Procurement Software
        • Indirect Procurement Software
        • Unified Source-to-Pay
        • Source-To-Contract Software
        • Procure-to-Pay
        • GEP SMART for Midsize & High-Growth Enterprises
        • Key Capabilities
        • Spend Analysis
        • Sourcing
        • Contract Lifecycle Management
        • Supplier Lifecycle Management
        • Third-Party Risk Management
        • Purchasing
        • Payments
        • Data Analytics and Reporting
        • Do More With GEP SMART
        • Intake Management & Orchestration
        • Intelligent Category Management
        • Tail Spend Management
        • Cost Data & Analytics (GEP COSTDRIVERS)

        GEP NEXXE

        • AI-First Supply Chain Management
        • Supply Chain Visibility and Execution
        • Logistics Visibility  
        • Inventory and Warehouse Management
        • GEP Multienterprise Collaboration Network
        • Supply Chain Control Tower
        • Field Services  
        • Supply Chain Collaboration & Planning  
        • Supply Chain Planning
        • Purchase Order Collaboration  
        • Forecast Collaboration 
        • Capacity Collaboration  
        • Quality Management Software  
        • Should-Cost Modeling
        • Direct Material Sourcing
        GEP Is a Leader in the 2025 Gartner® Magic Quadrant™ for Source-to-Pay Suites

        GEP Is a Leader in the 2025 Gartner® Magic Quadrant™ for Source-to-Pay Suites

        Read More

        GEP FINA

        • E-Invoice Network
        • E-Invoice Receiving
        • E-Invoice Sending
        • E-Invoicing Compliance
        • Digital Supply Chain
        GEP Is a Leader in the 2025 Gartner® Magic Quadrant™ for Source-to-Pay Suites

        GEP Is a Leader in the 2025 Gartner® Magic Quadrant™ for Source-to-Pay Suites

        Read More

        GEP QUANTUM

        • AI, ML & Automated Technology
        • AI-Powered Data Analytics
        • Cloud Integration
        • Low-Code Application Development
        GEP Is a Leader in the 2025 Gartner® Magic Quadrant™ for Source-to-Pay Suites

        GEP Is a Leader in the 2025 Gartner® Magic Quadrant™ for Source-to-Pay Suites

        Read More

        Strategy

        Unrivaled supply chain and procurement expertise + the transformative power of AI

        Procurement Consulting

        • Procurement Transformation
        • Digital Procurement Transformation
        • Opportunity Assessment
        • M&A Services

        Supply Chain Consulting

        • Environmental, Social and Governance
        • Sustainability Consulting Services
        • Socially Responsible Sourcing
        • Scope 3
        A Procurement Software Platforms Leader — 4 Years Running

        Tariff Resource Center: Strategies and Action Plans 

        Read More

        Procurement Consulting

        • Procurement Transformation
        • Digital Procurement Transformation
        • Opportunity Assessment
        • M & A Services
        • Strategic Cost Management
        • Supply Risk Management
        6 Strategies for CPG Companies To Supercharge Sales and Operations Planning

        6 Strategies for CPG Companies To Supercharge Sales and Operations Planning

        Read More

        Supply Chain Consulting

        • Environmental, Social and Governance
        • Sustainability Consulting Services
        • Socially Responsible Sourcing
        • Supply Chain Strategy
        • Supply Chain Diagnostics
        • Inventory Optimization
        • Network Optimization
        • GEP Total Inventory Management Solution
        Mapping & Reducing Scope 3 Emissions: A Quickstart Guide for Procurement Pros

        10 Practical Steps To Reduce Scope 3 Emissions

        Read More

        Managed Services

        World-class skills, experience and know-how — amplified by the power of AI

        Procurement Outsourcing

        • Source-to-Contract
        • Spend Analysis 
        • Procure-to-Pay
        • Cost Recovery & Invoice Auditing

        Supply Chain Outsourcing

        • Planning & Forecasting
        • Inventory Management
        • Logistics Management
        • Supply Chain Data Management
        GEP Named a Leader in Procurement Outsourcing Services

        GEP Named a Leader in Procurement Outsourcing Services

        Read More

        Procurement Outsourcing

        • Source-to-Contract
        • Spend Analysis
        • Strategic Sourcing
        • Category Management
        • Tail-Spend Management
        • Procurement Support Services
        • Procure-to-Pay
        • Cost Recovery & Invoice Auditing
        • Accounts Payable
        GEP Named a Leader in Procurement Outsourcing Services

        GEP Named a Leader in Procurement Outsourcing Services

        Read More

        Supply Chain Outsourcing

        • Planning & Forecasting
        • Inventory Management
        • Logistics Management
        • Supply Chain Data Management
        • Supply Chain Risk Management
        GEP Named a Leader in Procurement Outsourcing Services

        Expanding the Possibilities for Procurement and Supply Chain Management by Using AI

        Read More
    • Industries  
        • Explore by Industry 

        Explore by Industry

        • Automotive
        • Chemicals
        • Consumer Packaged Goods
        • Energy & Utilities
        • Financial Services
        • Government & Nonprofit
        • Industrial Manufacturing
        • Life Sciences
        • Oil & Gas
        • Private Equity
        • Retail
        • Telecommunications, Media & Technology
        • High-Tech
        • Media & Entertainment
        • Software, Social & Platforms
        • Telecom
        • Travel & Hospitality
    • Knowledge Bank  
        • Explore by Topic 
        • Explore by Type 
        • Global Supply Chain Volatility Index

        Explore by Topic

        • Artificial Intelligence
        • Digital Transformation
        • Software & Technology
        • Strategy & Planning
        • Operations
        • Procurement
        • Sustainability
        • Inflation Strategies
        A Procurement Software Platforms Leader — 4 Years Running

        Tariff Resource Center: Strategies and Action Plans 

        Read More

        Explore by Type

        • White Papers
        • Research Reports
        • Bulletin
        • Case Studies
        • Webcasts
        • Blogs
        • Podcasts
        • Insights From the Top
        • Glossary
        Resilience: Delivering Value Amid Volatility

        Resilience: Delivering Value Amid Volatility

        Read More

        Global Supply Chain Volatility Index

    • Careers
      • Join Us
      • GEP Per Se
      • Campus Connect
    • Partners
       
    • GEP Software ›
      • GEP Software
      • ‹ Back
        • GEP SMART ›
          • GEP SMART
          • ‹ Back
            • Procurement Software
            • Direct Procurement Software ›
              • Direct Procurement Software
              • ‹ Back
                • Bill of Materials Management
                • Data Analytics & Reporting
                • Inventory Management
                • Master Data Management
                • Quality Management
                • Supplier Collaboration Portal
                • Supply Chain Operations
            • Indirect Procurement Software ›
              • Indirect Procurement Software
              • ‹ Back
                • Source-to-Contract
                • Savings Project Management
                • Savings Tracking
                • Guided Buying
                • Procurement Portal
                • Catalog Management
                • Order Processing
                • Invoice Management
            • Unified Source-to-Pay
            • Source-To-Contract Software
            • Procure-to-Pay
            • Midsize & High Growth Enterprises
            • Key Capabilities
            • Spend Analysis
            • Sourcing
            • Contract Lifecycle Management
            • Supplier Lifecycle Management
            • Third-Party Risk Management
            • Purchasing
            • Payments
            • Data Analytics and Reporting
            • Do more with GEP SMART
            • Intake Management & Orchestration
            • Intelligent Category Management
            • Tail Spend Management
            • Cost Data & Analytics (GEP COSTDRIVERS)
        • GEP NEXXE ›
          • GEP NEXXE
          • ‹ Back
            • AI-First Supply Chain Management
            • Supply Chain Visibility and Execution ›
              • Supply Chain Visibility and Execution
              • ‹ Back
                • Inventory and Warehouse Management
                • Control Tower
            • Logistics Visibility
            • Inventory and Warehouse Management
            • GEP Multienterprise Collaboration Network
            • Supply Chain Control Tower
            • Field Services
            • Supply Chain Collaboration & Planning ›
              • Supply Chain Collaboration & Planning
              • ‹ Back
                • Purchase Order Collaboration
                • Quality Collaboration
            • Supply Chain Planning ›
              • Supply Chain Planning
              • ‹ Back
                • Demand Planning
                • Supply Chain Bill of Materials
                • Supply Planning
            • Purchase Order Collaboration
            • Forecast Collaboration
            • Capacity Collaboration
            • Quality Management Software
            • Should-Cost Modeling
            • Direct Material Sourcing
        • GEP FINA ›
          • GEP FINA
          • ‹ Back
            • E-Invoice Network
            • E-Invoice Receiving
            • E-Invoice Sending
            • E-Invoicing Compliance
            • Digital Supply Chain
        • GEP QUANTUM ›
          • GEP QUANTUM
          • ‹ Back
            • AI, ML & Automated Technology
            • AI-Powered Data Analytics
            • Cloud Integration
            • Low-Code Application Development
        • GEP GREEN
        • Innovation ›
          • Innovation
          • ‹ Back
            • Emerging Technologies
            • Native to Cloud
            • Native to Mobile
            • One Unified Platform
            • Security
            • User-Centric Design
    • GEP Strategy ›
      • GEP Strategy
      • ‹ Back
        • Procurement Consulting ›
          • Procurement Consulting
          • ‹ Back
            • Procurement Transformation ›
              • Procurement Transformation
              • ‹ Back
                • Procurement Strategy
                • Org. Design & Implementation
                • Capability Building
                • Change Management
                • Governance & Performance
                • Processes & Policies
                • S2P Operations
                • Sourcing & Category Management
                • Technology
            • Digital Procurement Transformation
            • Opportunity Assessment
            • M&A Services ›
              • M&A Services
              • ‹ Back
                • M&A Clean Room
            • Strategic Cost Management ›
              • Strategic Cost Management
              • ‹ Back
                • Zero-Based Budgeting
            • Supply Chain Risk Management
        • Supply Chain Consulting ›
          • Supply Chain Consulting
          • ‹ Back
            • Environmental, Social and Governance
            • Sustainability Consulting Services
            • Socially Responsible Sourcing
            • Scope 3
            • Demand and Supply Chain Planning
            • Collaborative Planning
            • Source To Contract
            • Procure To Pay
            • Inventory Strategy & Management
            • Operations & Manufacturing Excellence
            • GEP Total Inventory Management Solution
            • Network Strategy & Optimization
            • Warehousing & Transportation Management
    • GEP Managed Services ›
      • GEP Managed Services
      • ‹ Back
        • Procurement Outsourcing ›
          • Procurement Outsourcing
          • ‹ Back
            • Source-to-Contract
            • Spend Analysis
            • Strategic Sourcing ›
              • Strategic Sourcing
              • ‹ Back
                • MRO
                • CAPEX
                • Logistics
                • Packaging
                • IT & Telecom
                • Energy
                • Direct Materials
            • Category Management ›
              • Category Management
              • ‹ Back
                • Contract Management
                • Supplier Performance Management
                • Savings & Compliance Tracking
            • Supply Market Intelligence  
            • Tail-Spend Management Services
            • Procurement Support Services ›
              • Procurement Support Services
              • ‹ Back
                • eSourcing
                • Supplier Performance Management
                • Savings & Compliance Tracking
                • Sourcing Support
            • Procure-to-Pay
            • Cost Recovery & Invoice Auditing
            • Accounts Payable
        • Supply Chain Outsourcing ›
          • Supply Chain Outsourcing
          • ‹ Back
            • Planning & Forecasting
            • Inventory Management
            • Logistics Management
            • Supply Chain Data Management
            • Supply Risk Management
    • Industries ›
      • Industries
      • ‹ Back
        • Automotive
        • Chemicals
        • Consumer Packaged Goods
        • Energy & Utilities
        • Financial Services
        • Government & Nonprofit
        • Industrial Manufacturing
        • Life Sciences
        • Oil & Gas
        • Private Equity
        • Retail
        • Telecommunications, Media & Technology
        • High-Tech
        • Media & Entertainment
        • Software, Social & Platforms
        • Telecom
        • Travel & Hospitality
    • Knowledge Bank ›
      • Knowledge Bank
      • ‹ Back
        • Explore by Topic ›
          • Explore by Topic
          • ‹ Back
            • Artificial Intelligence
            • Digital Transformation
            • Operations
            • Procurement
            • Software & Technology
            • Strategy & Planning
            • Sustainability
            • Inflation Strategies
        • Explore by Type ›
          • Explore by Type
          • ‹ Back
            • Insights From the Top
            • White Papers
            • Research Reports
            • Bulletins
            • Case Studies
            • Webcasts
            • Blogs
            • Podcasts
            • Glossary
        • Global Supply Chain Volatility Index
    • Company ›
      • Company
      • ‹ Back
        • About Us
        • Leadership
        • Customers
        • Partners
        • AI-First at GEP
        • Sustainability at GEP
        • News
        • Events
        • Culture ›
          • Culture
          • ‹ Back
            • GEP Core Values
            • Women@GEP
            • Diversity
            • GEP Cares
        • Mission & Vision
        • Awards & Recognition
        • Contact Us
    • Global Presence ›
      • Global Presence
      • ‹ Back
        • Americas ›
          • Americas
          • ‹ Back
            • English
            • Español
            • Portugués
        • Europe ›
          • Europe
          • ‹ Back
            • English
            • Deutsch
        • Asia-Pacific ›
          • Asia-Pacific
          • ‹ Back
            • English
            • 中文
        • Middle East ›
          • Middle East
          • ‹ Back
            • English
            • العربية
    • Contact Us
    • Careers ›
      • Careers
      • ‹ Back
        • GEP Per Se
        • Campus Connect
    • Language ›
      • Language
      • ‹ Back
        • English
        • Français
        • Español
        • Deutsch
        • Italia
        • Português
        • 简体中文
        • 日本語
    • BLOGS
    • Strategy
    • Technology
    • MIND
     
    •  
    •  
    •  
    •  
    Blog Image

    Simplifying the Way Agencies Are Compensated

    November 06, 2017 | Marketing

    In a bid to drive simplicity in their relationships with agencies, advertisers are increasingly adopting commission-based pricing models. The move toward commission-based pricing models is a direct result of their awareness of the fact that other widely adopted pricing models are complex and are not as effective as they seemed. This awareness stems from the study conducted by the Association of National Advertisers (ANA), in 2016, which revealed the unethical practices followed by advertising agencies.

    As advertisers began to dig deeper into their agency contacts, their concern regarding transparency grew. In addition, they also discovered certain inefficiencies pertaining to agency compensation. These factors influenced their perspective on their agency relationships, leading advertisers to look more closely at agency compensation.  

    The sentiment regarding agency compensation also reverberates in a recent survey conducted by ANA, covering 82 companies representing more than 1,100 client/agency compensation agreements. The findings of the survey were released as a report titled “Trends in Agency Compensation,” published this year. The report points out that the rate of adoption of popular compensation models such as incentive-based compensation as well as fee-based compensation has declined since 2013.

    Advertisers are increasingly becoming skeptical regarding their agency incentive plans which include the bonus an agency earns if it meets predetermined performance goals. The report states that many advertisers find structuring and managing an effective incentive plan to be complicated and time consuming, as well as inadequate in improving agency performance. It was also recorded that there is an increase in the number of respondents, from 13 percent in 2013 to 22 percent in 2017, who claimed incentives negatively affected agency performance. As a result, there has been a significant decline in the adoption of incentive-based fee for the first time in the 50 years of the ANA survey. Like incentive plans, the adoption of fee-based compensation model also fell from a high of 81 percent in 2013 to 68 percent in 2016.

    In contrast, commission-based agency payment (i.e., pay based on a percentage of spend) as a compensation model rose to 12 percent in 2016 from 3 percent adoption in 2010. However, this trend varies significantly by the type of agency and service offerings. According to the report, 24 percent of compensation agreements with media planning/buying agencies are commission based, whereas just 6 percent of compensation agreements with creative agencies are commission based. Also, commissions are more frequently paid for programmatic buying, traditional media buying, and planning services than for social media and digital services.

    This implies that, though the adoption of a commission-based compensation is clearly on the rise, there shouldn’t be a “one size fits all” approach when aiming to simplify agency relationships. For example, traditional commissions might be perfectly appropriate for certain media functions, labor-based retainer fees are effectively employed for ongoing annual creative agency activity, and fixed project fees are better suited for less frequent and/or unplanned promotional events and PR initiatives.

    As advertisers eagerly look to simplify agency relationships as well as maximize their return on the agency compensation, agencies themselves are trying to remain profitable with rebates. Given this scenario, setting up a mutually beneficial compensation method is really difficult.

    To overcome this challenge, advertisers should ensure that the compensation method adopted aligns to their business goals, i.e., selecting the appropriate compensation model for a specific marketing service.  It is also important for advertisers to have a clear internal alignment on agency budgets and their approach toward negotiations. Any changes/reductions in compensation without clarity and rationale will erode the agency relationship, resulting in a sub-optimal agency performance and a rift in advertiser-agency relationship.

    Source:

    • https://www.ana.net/content/show/id/44647
    • https://www.wsj.com/articles/advertisers-seek-to-simplify-agency-pay-by-reviving-commissions-1495481309
    • https://www.thedrum.com/news/2017/05/23/commission-based-compensation-gaining-ground-marketers-seek-simplify-agency-pay
    • http://www.chiefmarketer.com/advertisers-simplify-agency-compensation-models/
    • https://www.marketingprofs.com/charts/2017/32204/how-marketing-and-advertising-agencies-are-compensated
     

    Tags: maximizing marketing ROI

    Add Comment +

    GEP Outlook 2025: Procurement & Supply Chain Key Trends, Challenges and Opportunities

    Read More

    FEATURED POST

    ...
    Risk Management

    Act Now or Play Safe? Here’s How to Respond to Tariff Uncertainty

    ...
    Supply Chain Strategy

    The AI Race Isn’t Just About Tech — It’s About Supply Chain Agility

    ...
    Source to Pay

    From Vision to Execution: Why GEP Is a Leader for S2P Suites in Gartner 2024-25 Magic Quadrant

      BLOG CATEGORIES

    • Marketing
    • Pharma and Life Sciences
    • Professional Services
    • IT & Telecom
    • Logistics
    • Chemicals
    • Energy & Utilities
    • Market Intelligence
    • Oil and Gas
    • Supply Chain
    • MRO
    • Facilities Management
    • Human Resource
    • Agro
    • Packaging
    • CAPEX
    • Procurement Process and Excellence
    • Direct Materials
    • Automotives
    • Healthcare
    • Metals & Minerals
    • Corporate Travel
    • Technology
    • Category Management
    • Awards and Events

    TAGS

    sustainability
    Procurement Software
    supply chain strategy
    Inflation
    Russia-Ukraine War

    By checking the box below, you consent to GEP using your personal information to send you thought leadership content – such as white papers, research reports, case studies – and other communications. GEP representatives may contact you to provide additional information or answer questions.

    If at any point in time you decide to withdraw your consent, you may unsubscribe by emailing your request to us at privacy@gep.com.

    Please refer to the GEP Privacy Statement to understand how we manage and protect your personal information.

    Terms of Use | Privacy Statement

    SEND US YOUR QUESTION(S)

    By checking the box below, you consent to receiving thought capital – such as white papers, webinars, news and research – and other communications from GEP. When you download an asset, GEP representatives may contact you to provide additional information or answer questions.

    GEP will never sell or share your information with anyone. You may opt-out at any time. Please refer to the GEP privacy statement to understand how we manage and protect your personal information.

    If you choose to withdraw your consent in the future, you may do so by emailing your request to privacy@gep.com

    Terms of Use | Privacy Statement

    Breadcrumb

    1. HOME
    2. BLOGS
    3. MARKET INTELLIGENCE
    4. SIMPLIFYING THE WAY AGENCIES ARE COMPENSATED

    Contact Us

      Demo Schedule a live demo of our software
      RFP Request for a business proposal
      Ask Us Send us your question(s)
      Feedback Share your comments and suggestions
           
    STRATEGY
    Strategy
    •   Procurement Consulting
    •   Digital Procurement Transformation
    •   Strategic Cost Management
    •   Opportunity Assessment
    •   Supply Chain Risk Management
    •   Supply Chain Consulting
    •   Supply Chain Strategy
    •   Supply Chain Diagnostics
    •   Inventory Optimization
    •   Procurement Transformation
    •   Sustainability and ESG Consulting
    SOFTWARE
    Software
    •   Procurement Software
    •   Supply Chain Software
    •   Source-to-Contract
    •   Procure-to-Pay
    •   Supply Chain Planning
    •   Supply Chain Collaboration
    •   Supply Chain Visibility & Execution
    •   Supply Chain Control Tower
    •   Should-Cost Modeling
    •   Inventory & Warehouse Management Software
    •   Source-To-Pay Software
    •   Midsize & High Growth Enterprises
    MANAGED SERVICES
    Managed Services
    •   Procurement Outsourcing
    •   Strategic Sourcing
    •   Tail-Spend Management
    •   Category Management
    •   Procurement Support Services
    •   Supply Chain Outsourcing
    •   Supply Chain Planning & Forecasting
    •   Inventory Management
    •   Logistics Management
    COMPANY
    Company
    •   About Us
    •   Leadership
    •   Customers
    •   Sustainability at GEP
    •   Careers
    •   News
    •   Awards
    •   Partners
    •   Contact Us
    Stay Connected

       
       

    Download the GEP GO App

    Stay connected with cutting-edge procurement and supply chain insights – anytime, anywhere.

    app store
    play store
    © Copyright GEP 2025. All rights reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Statement | Cookie Policy |  Cookie Settings | Quality Policy | GEP Logo