Skip to main content
  • login
  • contact
  • language
    • English
    • Français
    • Español
    • Português
    • Deutsch
    • 简体中文
    • 日本語
  • search
X
GEP Logo GEP Logo
  • Company
    • Leadership
    • Customers
    • Partners
    • Sustainability at GEP
    • News
    • Events
    • Culture
    • Mission & Vision
    • Awards & Recognition
  • Solutions
    • Strategy
      • Procurement Consulting  
        • Procurement Transformation
        • Digital Procurement Transformation
        • Opportunity Assessment
        • M & A Services
        • Strategic Cost Management
        • Supply Risk Management
      • Supply Chain Consulting  
        • Environmental, Social and Governance
        • Socially Responsible Sourcing
        • Supply Chain Strategy
        • Supply Chain Diagnostics
        • Inventory Optimization
        • Network Optimization
      Software
      • GEP SMART  
        • Procurement Software
        • Direct Procurement Software
        • Indirect Procurement Software
        • Digital Procurement Transformation
        • Master Data Management
        • AP Automation
        • Spend Management
        • SMART S2P Technology
      • GEP NEXXE  
        • Supply Chain Visibility and Execution
        • Supply Chain Planning
        • Supply Chain Collaboration
        • Supply Chain Control Tower
        • Should-Cost Modeling
        • Inventory and Warehouse Management
      • GEP CLICK  
      • GEP MINERVA  
      Managed Services
      • Procurement Outsourcing  
        • Source-to-Contract
          • Spend Analysis
          • Strategic Sourcing
          • Category Management
          • Supply Market Intelligence
          • Tail-Spend Management
          • Procurement Support Services
        • Procure-to-Pay
          • Cost Recovery & Invoice Auditing
          • Accounts Payable
      • Supply Chain Outsourcing  
        • Planning & Forecasting
        • Inventory Management
        • Logistics Management
        • Supply Chain Data Management
        • Supply Chain Risk Management
  • Industries
    • Automotive
    • Chemicals
    • Consumer Packaged Goods
    • Energy & Utilities
    • Financial Services
    • Government & Nonprofit
    • Industrial Manufacturing
    • Life Sciences
    • Oil & Gas
    • Retail
    • Telecommunications, Media & Technology
    • High-Tech
    • Media & Entertainment
    • Software, Social & Platforms
    • Telecom
    • Travel & Hospitality
  • Knowledge Bank
    • Digital Transformation
    • Software & Technology
    • Strategy & Planning
    • Operations
    • Procurement
    • Sustainability
    • Insights From the Top
    • COVID-19 Resource Center
    • Inflation Strategies
  • Careers
    • Join Us
    • GEP Per Se
    • Campus Connect
  • Partners
   
  • GEP Strategy ›
    • GEP Strategy
    • ‹ Back
      • Procurement Consulting ›
        • Procurement Consulting
        • ‹ Back
          • Procurement Transformation ›
            • Procurement Transformation
            • ‹ Back
              • Procurement Strategy
              • Org. Design & Implementation
              • Capability Building
              • Change Management
              • Governance & Performance
              • Processes & Policies
              • S2P Operations
              • Sourcing & Category Management
              • Technology
          • Digital Procurement Transformation
          • Opportunity Assessment
          • M&A Services ›
            • M&A Services
            • ‹ Back
              • M&A Clean Room
          • Strategic Cost Management ›
            • Strategic Cost Management
            • ‹ Back
              • Zero-Based Budgeting
          • Supply Chain Risk Management
      • Supply Chain Consulting ›
        • Supply Chain Consulting
        • ‹ Back
          • SUSTAINABILITY AND RESILIENCE
          • Environmental, Social and Governance
          • Socially Responsible Sourcing
          • Scope 3
          • PLAN
          • Digital Planning, S&OP, S&OE
          • Collaborative Planning
          • PROCURE
          • Source To Contract
          • Procure To Pay
          • MAKE
          • Inventory Strategy & Management
          • Operations & Manufacturing Excellence
          • DELIVER
          • Network Strategy & Optimization
          • Warehousing & Transportation Management
  • GEP Software ›
    • GEP Software
    • ‹ Back
      • GEP SMART ›
        • GEP SMART
        • ‹ Back
          • Procurement Software
          • Direct Procurement Software ›
            • Direct Procurement Software
            • ‹ Back
              • Bill of Materials Management
              • Data Analytics & Reporting
              • Inventory Management
              • Master Data Management
              • Quality Management
              • Supplier Collaboration Portal
              • Supply Chain Operations
          • Indirect Procurement Software ›
            • Indirect Procurement Software
            • ‹ Back
              • Source-to-Contract
              • Spend Analysis
              • Savings Project Management
              • Category Management
              • Contract Management
              • Savings Tracking
              • Sourcing
              • Supplier Management
              • Procure-to-Pay
              • Guided Buying
              • Procurement Portal
              • Catalog Management
              • Order Processing
              • Invoice Management
          • Digital Procurement Transformation
          • Master Data Management
          • Product Accessibility
          • AP Automation
          • Spend Management
          • SMART S2P Technology
      • GEP NEXXE ›
        • GEP NEXXE
        • ‹ Back
          • Supply Chain Visibility and Execution ›
            • Supply Chain Visibility and Execution
            • ‹ Back
              • Inventory and Warehouse Management
              • Logistics Visibility
              • Control Tower
          • Supply Chain Planning ›
            • Supply Chain Planning
            • ‹ Back
              • Supply Chain Control Tower
              • Should-Cost Modeling
              • Demand Planning
              • Supply Chain Bill of Materials
              • Supply Chain Direct Sourcing
              • Supply Planning
          • Supply Chain Collaboration ›
            • Supply Chain Collaboration
            • ‹ Back
              • Forecast Collaboration
              • Purchase Order Collaboration
              • Quality Collaboration
              • Capacity Collaboration
              • Quality Management Software
          • Supply Chain Control Tower
          • Should-Cost Modeling
          • Inventory and Warehouse Management
      • GEP CLICK
      • GEP MINERVA
      • Innovation ›
        • Innovation
        • ‹ Back
          • Emerging Technologies
          • Native to Cloud
          • Native to Mobile
          • One Unified Platform
          • Security
          • User-Centric Design
  • GEP Managed Services ›
    • GEP Managed Services
    • ‹ Back
      • Procurement Outsourcing ›
        • Procurement Outsourcing
        • ‹ Back
          • Source-to-Contract
          • Spend Analysis
          • Strategic Sourcing ›
            • Strategic Sourcing
            • ‹ Back
              • MRO
              • CAPEX
              • Logistics
              • Packaging
              • IT & Telecom
              • Energy
              • Direct Materials
          • Category Management ›
            • Category Management
            • ‹ Back
              • Contract Management
              • Supplier Performance Management
              • Savings & Compliance Tracking
          • Supply Market Intelligence
          • Tail-Spend Management
          • Procurement Support Services ›
            • Procurement Support Services
            • ‹ Back
              • eSourcing
              • Supplier Performance Management
              • Savings & Compliance Tracking
              • Sourcing Support
          • Procure-to-Pay
          • Cost Recovery & Invoice Auditing
          • Accounts Payable
      • Supply Chain Outsourcing ›
        • Supply Chain Outsourcing
        • ‹ Back
          • Planning & Forecasting
          • Inventory Management
          • Logistics Management
          • Supply Chain Data Management
          • Supply Risk Management
  • Industries ›
    • Industries
    • ‹ Back
      • Automotive
      • Chemicals
      • Consumer Packaged Goods
      • Energy & Utilities
      • Financial Services
      • Government & Nonprofit
      • Industrial Manufacturing
      • Life Sciences
      • Oil & Gas
      • Retail
      • Telecommunications, Media & Technology
      • High-Tech
      • Media & Entertainment
      • Software, Social & Platforms
      • Telecom
      • Travel & Hospitality
  • Knowledge Bank ›
    • Knowledge Bank
    • ‹ Back
      • Digital Transformation
      • Operations
      • Procurement
      • Software & Technology
      • Strategy & Planning
      • Sustainability
      • Podcasts
      • Insights from the Top
      • COVID-19 Resource Center
      • Inflation Strategies
  • Company ›
    • Company
    • ‹ Back
      • Leadership
      • Customers
      • Partners
      • Sustainability at GEP
      • News
      • Events
      • Culture ›
        • Culture
        • ‹ Back
          • GEP Core Values
          • Women@GEP
          • Diversity
          • GEP Cares
      • Mission & Vision
      • Awards & Recognition
      • Contact Us
  • Global Presence ›
    • Global Presence
    • ‹ Back
      • Americas ›
        • Americas
        • ‹ Back
          • English
          • Español
          • Portugués
      • Europe ›
        • Europe
        • ‹ Back
          • English
          • Deutsch
      • Asia-Pacific ›
        • Asia-Pacific
        • ‹ Back
          • English
          • 中文
      • Middle East ›
        • Middle East
        • ‹ Back
          • English
          • العربية
  • Contact Us
  • Careers ›
    • Careers
    • ‹ Back
      • Join Us
      • GEP Per Se
      • Campus Connect
  • Language ›
    • Language
    • ‹ Back
      • English
      • Français
      • Español
      • Deutsch
      • Português
      • 简体中文
      • 日本語
  • Rapid Response from GEP
  • BLOGS
  • Strategy
  • Technology
  • MIND
Contact Us
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Breadcrumb

  1. HOME
  2. BLOG
  3. STRATEGY
  4. PROCUREMENT MODEL DEAL WITH RELUCTANT BUDGET HOLDERS
Blog Image

Picking Your Procurement Battles: A Model to Deal with Reluctant Budget-Holders

  • As a baseline, a procurement policy usually meets little resistance when it aligns closely with the financial policy with regards to transactional elements.
  • Procurement is frequently allowed in at the leverage and tactical category spend areas, but it can fight to be part of the big strategic supply decisions that stakeholders own 
  • It's a mix of politics and rational decision-making in procurement that the best CPOs manage with aplomb without sacrificing broader company values.

August 26, 2022 | Procurement Strategy Blogs

One of the thorniest issues in private sector procurement is the spend pools that are “sacred cows”. Examples are abound.

  • The general counsel who negotiates all the legal providers
  • The marketing director who directly extends the ATL agency without competition
  • The CEO direct award to a strategy consulting house which is a 'done deal' as it crosses the professional buyers desk
  • The partnerships team- because its suppliers generate revenue for the business then it’s not a cost play and procurement doesn't get involved
  • The brokerage fees and other commissions that drive incentives and vary significantly

As a new CPO entering the post with ambition to make a difference, do you force yourself in or let it go (and hope, probably in vain) that you will be allowed in one day?

In the face of more powerful stakeholders, what does a CPO and her team do? 

This blog offers a decision framework for deciding the role for you to apply to your environment as you consider whether the fight is worth it.

Also Read: Your Perfect Procurement Investment Pitch Storyboard For C-Suite

The State of Play in Procurement's 'Reach' 

As a baseline, a procurement policy usually meets little resistance when it aligns closely with the financial policy with regards to transactional elements: all purchases must flow through approvals in an approved system, for example. 

The concept of using 'approved' suppliers where basic checks have been conducted is also widely accepted. This clearly supports payment, risk and financial controls as well as provides some audit trail and visibility. Besides, ‘placing an order’ has been a standard business practice for decades.

A positive concept that has gained traction in recent years is ‘guided buying’. Using a panel of preferred and/or approved suppliers (provided by the procurement team) and providing the end user an easy means of selecting those (or competing them). 

This supports procurement's extended influence, but the impact of this lever has (mostly) been on high-volume transactional areas. It has gained limited traction in 20% of the suppliers that account for 80% of a company spend.

Procurement policies that define the function as ‘custodian ‘of all external spend usually are over-reaching, given capacity constraints. Policies therefore tend to allow freedom to stakeholders to buy as they wish for low-value and low-risk purchases. 

The worst procurement policies are essentially “secure 3 quotes” before you buy.

Good procurement policies for larger buys usually stipulate to: (a) involve procurement and involve us early; (b) define your requirements optimally; (c) compete requirements wherever possible; (d) use good contract terms and (e) manage your suppliers effectively over the life of the engagement.

You’ll hardly find a procurement policy that has been enforced through sanctions. However, the involvement of procurement (or not, or a contract admin only) is the source of much frustration. Powerful stakeholders can often get away with a shrug and guffaw when they pseudo-sheepishly beg forgiveness for not following policy again.

Also read: How A New CPO Can Pick The Right Savings Transformation Flavor

Sidelining of Procurement... But Why? 

Putting yourself into the shoes of the budget-holder, you’ll see four main reasons for the sidelining:

  1. Company culture. Where a business has deemed that the business lines are entrepreneurs who need freedom to be agile and perform, then central shared service functions like procurement and HR will be viewed as ‘use when I need them only’, not functions that should always be consulted for major topics.
  2. Misalignment on priorities. There will a couple of unhealthy environments where the central functions are actively being avoided by the business units/ stakeholders on account of previous issues and misaligned goals.
  3. "Specialism". The unique character and complexity of our supply market landscape requires decades of experience that a junior would never bring value to. The stakeholders view themselves as the experts here.
  4. Procurement's reputation. Procurement slows things down, add unnecessary time and process to decision making. Or worse, seek to reduce budgets so they can justify their value to finance. They may even make the budget-holders’ team look like they've been asleep at the wheel, so they don't want procurement anywhere near.

The Battleground and Whether To Fight There 

In fairness to the stakeholder, procurement is frequently allowed in at the leverage and tactical category spend areas. Print in marketing. Software renewals in technology. Soft FM in facilities. However, it’s the big strategic supply decisions that stakeholders own where the battleground can exist.

The general principles of whether to pick a battle are widely written about:

  • Does the issue in question tie to one of your department or company priorities? Does it conflict with company values?
  • Even though you disagree with the idea or approach, can you live with it? Are you setting a precedent that if widely adopted would be damaging to your wider goal?
  • Has this person outwardly supported one of your ideas in the past? Can you 'trade' goodwill as a one-off to support a wider strategic aim?
  • Do you have allies you can call on that will support you? Or will you, despite strong rational arguments, be in a minority, nevertheless?
  • Does this battle have a neutral or positive impact on your health and the health of your team? Fighting involves personal risk, takes time, consumes energy. Is it worth it?

Taking all these inputs, the following decision model supports your strategy and tactics at a sub-category level:

Procurement Power Balance

On the ‘x’ axis is the probability of successfully enforcing change based on a judgement of the power balance right now. Factors that support the analysis of this dimension include:

  • Sponsorship from your board executive and her standing, based on the arguments/ business case
  • Timing/ the need to find value in the supply chain
  • Historical relationships and the extent central functions have enjoyed influence in the past

On the ‘y’ axis is the ‘knowledge’ held right now in the procurement team:

  • Are you an expert on the supply market (not just the procurement process)? Can you bring new ideas and insight that will trigger a difference in working practices (not merely, ‘lets run an RFP?’)
  • Is the purported ‘specialism’ of the spend pool surmountable? And does the procurement team possess it? Whilst many excellent generalists make a big impact on many categories, when faced with a resistant stakeholder, credibility in conversations is essential.

Based on these two dimensions, four options exist:

1.  Follow first (then lead)

The mantra can be “demonstrate the quick wins/value in the low-tension areas and we will earn the reputation to be involved upstream”. This has mixed long term results and carries risk. The middle management who typically look after these areas are indeed grateful recipients and become procurement's advocates. But this doesn't necessarily flow upwards.

2.  Lead  

Here's we've chosen to go for it. The battle is worth it, and we think we will win. Planning, communications and change management (and patience), alongside strategic sponsorship will all be critical here to insert procurement's expertise into the function.

3.  Follow where allowed or get out the way

Offer a one-year policy waiver. Provide a resource in as a token/bridgehead to stay close and provide support (and build attention). Be there to help and keep channels of communication open.

4.  Follow and build capability

Play the longer game. Take time to build knowledge: bring in external help (hire or from professional services firms). Poach a member of their team into your team as a secondee if you can. Conduct knowledge sharing and build bridges. Then make your play.

It's a mix of politics and rational decision-making in procurement that the best CPOs manage with aplomb without sacrificing broader company values. And it's always a fine balance. With a decision model as a guide, hopefully the journey will be easier.

Turn ideas into action. Talk to GEP.

GEP helps enterprise procurement and supply chain teams at hundreds of Fortune 500 and Global 2000 companies rapidly achieve more efficient, more effective operations, with greater reach, improved performance, and increased impact. To learn more about how we can help you, contact us today.

Graham Copeland
Senior Director- Business Development

Graham leads business development of the services organization for the UKI region. He has 25 years of procurement and sales leadership experience and has worked as an employee and a consultant with Schlumberger, Coop Group, Tesco Bank, BP, ABN Amro and Deutsche Bank. At GEP, he helps CPOs with operating model decisions and procurement transformations. He also runs the Proctopus procurement community. Graham holds a Bachelor’s degree in engineering and business from The University of Strathclyde.

LET'S TALK

 

Tags: cpo , Procurement Strategy , Procurement Software

Add Comment +

FEATURED POST

...
Supply Chain Strategy Blogs

How to Effectively Monitor Scope 3 Emission Reporting From Your Supply Chain

...
Supply Chain Software Blogs

From Cost to Resiliency: How Supply Chain Priorities Have Changed

    BLOG CATEGORIES

  • Supply Chain Strategy Blogs
  • Procurement Strategy Blogs
  • Sourcing Strategy Blogs
  • Miscellaneous Blogs
  • Risk Management Blogs
  • Supplier Management Strategy Blogs
  • M&A Blogs
  • Supply Chain Risk Management Blogs
  • Cost Management Blogs
  • Digital Supply Chain Transformation Blogs
  • Inventory Management Blogs
  • Inventory Management

TAGS

sustainability
Procurement Software
supply chain strategy
Inflation
Russia-Ukraine War

By checking the box below, you consent to GEP using your personal information to send you thought leadership content – such as white papers, research reports, case studies – and other communications. GEP representatives may contact you to provide additional information or answer questions.

If at any point in time you decide to withdraw your consent, you may unsubscribe by emailing your request to us at privacy@gep.com.

Please refer to the GEP Privacy Statement to understand how we manage and protect your personal information.

Terms of Use | Privacy Statement

Contact Us

Ask Us

Send us your question(s)

RFP

Request for a business proposal

Feedback

Share your thoughts, comments and suggestions

Demo

Schedule a live demo of our software

Discover
STRATEGY
Strategy
  •   Procurement Consulting
  •   Digital Procurement Transformation
  •   Strategic Cost Management
  •   Opportunity Assessment
  •   Supply Chain Risk Management
  •   Supply Chain Consulting
  •   Supply Chain Strategy
  •   Supply Chain Diagnostics
  •   Inventory Optimization
  •   Procurement Transformation
  •   Sustainability and ESG Consulting
SOFTWARE
Software
  •   Procurement Software
  •   Supply Chain Software
  •   Source-to-Contract
  •   Procure-to-Pay
  •   Supply Chain Planning
  •   Supply Chain Collaboration
  •   Supply Chain Visibility & Execution
  •   Supply Chain Control Tower
  •   Should-Cost Modeling
  •   Inventory & Warehouse Management Software
  •   Source-To-Pay Software
MANAGED SERVICES
Managed Services
  •   Procurement Outsourcing
  •   Strategic Sourcing
  •   Tail-Spend Management
  •   Category Management
  •   Procurement Support Services
  •   Supply Chain Outsourcing
  •   Supply Chain Planning & Forecasting
  •   Inventory Management
  •   Logistics Management
COMPANY
Company
  •   About Us
  •   Leadership
  •   Customers
  •   Sustainability at GEP
  •   Careers
  •   News
  •   Awards
  •   Partners
  •   Contact Us

Fresh Insights, Now on Your Phone

  • Dowmload On The App Store Button
Stay Connected
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Latest Tweets

  • We are delighted to announce @SubhashMakhija1, #GEP #CEO and Co-Founder, as the newest member of the CNBC CEO Counc… https://t.co/MNJXch4Vte

  • #Procurement leaders must develop a spend category management plan to power them through 2023 and beyond. #GEP’s Ry… https://t.co/5JxFw1UbsY

  • How can #automotive companies get the EV transition right? Electric vehicles may be the right option, but it’s not… https://t.co/WmGNCK6sFw

  • Conquering 2023 Supply Chain Setback - 31 Jan 2023 https://t.co/wg0MdRATfh

  • On the occasion of Republic Day in India, GEP Hyderabad held an art competition and GEPpers showed their creativity… https://t.co/NSHrXILbiv

  • We're proud to announce the extension of our #procurement services agreement with @Macys's Inc. to help drive… https://t.co/Hgn4uaGbW0

  • The #SupplyChain and #procurement #software market is in flux amid #MnA. If your software provider gets acquired, w… https://t.co/orQlKUZB4X

  • #SupplyChain #disruptions are a reality in today's unpredictable world. Learn how @gepsoftware has helped #SGS resp… https://t.co/jA2GnbWIBg

  • What steps can companies take to achieve #ESG goals effectively? Well, they can start with #procurement. Learn how… https://t.co/HGEfNyGdeD

  • #ElectricVehicles are a key part of the auto industry's plan to become #NetZero by 2050. But EVs aren't enough on t… https://t.co/YlEoys6vTA

  • Why did Asahi choose #GEP as their #procurement and #SupplyChain partner? Check out this video featuring Carmen Rad… https://t.co/RmstcfJXtm

  • GEPpers know how to have a good time! Check out a glimpse of our Winter Party at the GEP Prague office. We are hir… https://t.co/BqVK6XkpHv

  • #Inflation has dampened expectations for GDP growth and raised the risks of a #recession. What can #procurement lea… https://t.co/Hn1R5bxZXn

  • 4D seismic #technology is opening deep-sea #OilAndGas reserves for exploration, lowering costs and optimizing reser… https://t.co/Omq51vlEq7

  • The #GEP Europe Outlook 2023 Roadshow is coming to a city near you! Join us to learn the seven critical priorities… https://t.co/Hzv68et4Rr

  • GEP wishes a Happy Republic Day to all the Indians around the world.  We are #hiring. Explore our careers section:… https://t.co/RKTsyBfQFc

  • Sustainability Outlook for 2023: Trends, Insights and Actions 25 Jan 2023 https://t.co/58KIepy577

  • #Pharma companies are reshoring production, but shortages of active pharmaceutical ingredients make it a challenge.… https://t.co/a3uQJhn7tx

© Copyright GEP 2022. All rights reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Statement | Cookie Policy |   | Quality Policy | GEP Logo