Skip to main content
  • login
  • contact
  • language
    • English
    • Français
    • Español
    • Português
    • Deutsch
    • 简体中文
    • 日本語
  • search
X
GEP Logo GEP Logo
  • Company
    • Leadership
    • Customers
    • Partners
    • Sustainability at GEP
    • News
    • Events
    • Culture
    • Mission & Vision
    • Awards & Recognition
  • Solutions
    • Strategy
      • Procurement Consulting  
        • Procurement Transformation
        • Digital Procurement Transformation
        • Opportunity Assessment
        • M & A Services
        • Strategic Cost Management
        • Supply Risk Management
      • Supply Chain Consulting  
        • Environmental, Social and Governance
        • Socially Responsible Sourcing
        • Supply Chain Strategy
        • Supply Chain Diagnostics
        • Inventory Optimization
        • Network Optimization
      Software
      • GEP SMART  
        • Procurement Software
        • Direct Procurement Software
        • Indirect Procurement Software
        • Digital Procurement Transformation
        • Master Data Management
        • AP Automation
        • Spend Management
        • SMART S2P Technology
      • GEP NEXXE  
        • Supply Chain Visibility and Execution
        • Supply Chain Planning
        • Supply Chain Collaboration
        • Supply Chain Control Tower
        • Should-Cost Modeling
        • Inventory and Warehouse Management
      • GEP CLICK  
      • GEP MINERVA  
      Managed Services
      • Procurement Outsourcing  
        • Source-to-Contract
          • Spend Analysis
          • Strategic Sourcing
          • Category Management
          • Supply Market Intelligence
          • Tail-Spend Management
          • Procurement Support Services
        • Procure-to-Pay
          • Cost Recovery & Invoice Auditing
          • Accounts Payable
      • Supply Chain Outsourcing  
        • Planning & Forecasting
        • Inventory Management
        • Logistics Management
        • Supply Chain Data Management
        • Supply Chain Risk Management
  • Industries
    • Automotive
    • Chemicals
    • Consumer Packaged Goods
    • Energy & Utilities
    • Financial Services
    • Government & Nonprofit
    • Industrial Manufacturing
    • Life Sciences
    • Oil & Gas
    • Retail
    • Telecommunications, Media & Technology
    • High-Tech
    • Media & Entertainment
    • Software, Social & Platforms
    • Telecom
    • Travel & Hospitality
  • Knowledge Bank
    • Digital Transformation
    • Software & Technology
    • Strategy & Planning
    • Operations
    • Procurement
    • Sustainability
    • Insights From the Top
    • COVID-19 Resource Center
    • Inflation Strategies
  • Careers
    • Join Us
    • GEP Per Se
    • Campus Connect
  • Partners
   
  • GEP Strategy ›
    • GEP Strategy
    • ‹ Back
      • Procurement Consulting ›
        • Procurement Consulting
        • ‹ Back
          • Procurement Transformation ›
            • Procurement Transformation
            • ‹ Back
              • Procurement Strategy
              • Org. Design & Implementation
              • Capability Building
              • Change Management
              • Governance & Performance
              • Processes & Policies
              • S2P Operations
              • Sourcing & Category Management
              • Technology
          • Digital Procurement Transformation
          • Opportunity Assessment
          • M&A Services ›
            • M&A Services
            • ‹ Back
              • M&A Clean Room
          • Strategic Cost Management ›
            • Strategic Cost Management
            • ‹ Back
              • Zero-Based Budgeting
          • Supply Chain Risk Management
      • Supply Chain Consulting ›
        • Supply Chain Consulting
        • ‹ Back
          • SUSTAINABILITY AND RESILIENCE
          • Environmental, Social and Governance
          • Socially Responsible Sourcing
          • Scope 3
          • PLAN
          • Digital Planning, S&OP, S&OE
          • Collaborative Planning
          • PROCURE
          • Source To Contract
          • Procure To Pay
          • MAKE
          • Inventory Strategy & Management
          • Operations & Manufacturing Excellence
          • DELIVER
          • Network Strategy & Optimization
          • Warehousing & Transportation Management
  • GEP Software ›
    • GEP Software
    • ‹ Back
      • GEP SMART ›
        • GEP SMART
        • ‹ Back
          • Procurement Software
          • Direct Procurement Software ›
            • Direct Procurement Software
            • ‹ Back
              • Bill of Materials Management
              • Data Analytics & Reporting
              • Inventory Management
              • Master Data Management
              • Quality Management
              • Supplier Collaboration Portal
              • Supply Chain Operations
          • Indirect Procurement Software ›
            • Indirect Procurement Software
            • ‹ Back
              • Source-to-Contract
              • Spend Analysis
              • Savings Project Management
              • Category Management
              • Contract Management
              • Savings Tracking
              • Sourcing
              • Supplier Management
              • Procure-to-Pay
              • Guided Buying
              • Procurement Portal
              • Catalog Management
              • Order Processing
              • Invoice Management
          • Digital Procurement Transformation
          • Master Data Management
          • Product Accessibility
          • AP Automation
          • Spend Management
          • SMART S2P Technology
      • GEP NEXXE ›
        • GEP NEXXE
        • ‹ Back
          • Supply Chain Visibility and Execution ›
            • Supply Chain Visibility and Execution
            • ‹ Back
              • Inventory and Warehouse Management
              • Logistics Visibility
              • Control Tower
          • Supply Chain Planning ›
            • Supply Chain Planning
            • ‹ Back
              • Supply Chain Control Tower
              • Should-Cost Modeling
              • Demand Planning
              • Supply Chain Bill of Materials
              • Supply Chain Direct Sourcing
              • Supply Planning
          • Supply Chain Collaboration ›
            • Supply Chain Collaboration
            • ‹ Back
              • Forecast Collaboration
              • Purchase Order Collaboration
              • Quality Collaboration
              • Capacity Collaboration
              • Quality Management Software
          • Supply Chain Control Tower
          • Should-Cost Modeling
          • Inventory and Warehouse Management
      • GEP CLICK
      • GEP MINERVA
      • Innovation ›
        • Innovation
        • ‹ Back
          • Emerging Technologies
          • Native to Cloud
          • Native to Mobile
          • One Unified Platform
          • Security
          • User-Centric Design
  • GEP Managed Services ›
    • GEP Managed Services
    • ‹ Back
      • Procurement Outsourcing ›
        • Procurement Outsourcing
        • ‹ Back
          • Source-to-Contract
          • Spend Analysis
          • Strategic Sourcing ›
            • Strategic Sourcing
            • ‹ Back
              • MRO
              • CAPEX
              • Logistics
              • Packaging
              • IT & Telecom
              • Energy
              • Direct Materials
          • Category Management ›
            • Category Management
            • ‹ Back
              • Contract Management
              • Supplier Performance Management
              • Savings & Compliance Tracking
          • Supply Market Intelligence
          • Tail-Spend Management
          • Procurement Support Services ›
            • Procurement Support Services
            • ‹ Back
              • eSourcing
              • Supplier Performance Management
              • Savings & Compliance Tracking
              • Sourcing Support
          • Procure-to-Pay
          • Cost Recovery & Invoice Auditing
          • Accounts Payable
      • Supply Chain Outsourcing ›
        • Supply Chain Outsourcing
        • ‹ Back
          • Planning & Forecasting
          • Inventory Management
          • Logistics Management
          • Supply Chain Data Management
          • Supply Risk Management
  • Industries ›
    • Industries
    • ‹ Back
      • Automotive
      • Chemicals
      • Consumer Packaged Goods
      • Energy & Utilities
      • Financial Services
      • Government & Nonprofit
      • Industrial Manufacturing
      • Life Sciences
      • Oil & Gas
      • Retail
      • Telecommunications, Media & Technology
      • High-Tech
      • Media & Entertainment
      • Software, Social & Platforms
      • Telecom
      • Travel & Hospitality
  • Knowledge Bank ›
    • Knowledge Bank
    • ‹ Back
      • Digital Transformation
      • Operations
      • Procurement
      • Software & Technology
      • Strategy & Planning
      • Sustainability
      • Podcasts
      • Insights from the Top
      • COVID-19 Resource Center
      • Inflation Strategies
  • Company ›
    • Company
    • ‹ Back
      • Leadership
      • Customers
      • Partners
      • Sustainability at GEP
      • News
      • Events
      • Culture ›
        • Culture
        • ‹ Back
          • GEP Core Values
          • Women@GEP
          • Diversity
          • GEP Cares
      • Mission & Vision
      • Awards & Recognition
      • Contact Us
  • Global Presence ›
    • Global Presence
    • ‹ Back
      • Americas ›
        • Americas
        • ‹ Back
          • English
          • Español
          • Portugués
      • Europe ›
        • Europe
        • ‹ Back
          • English
          • Deutsch
      • Asia-Pacific ›
        • Asia-Pacific
        • ‹ Back
          • English
          • 中文
      • Middle East ›
        • Middle East
        • ‹ Back
          • English
          • العربية
  • Contact Us
  • Careers ›
    • Careers
    • ‹ Back
      • Join Us
      • GEP Per Se
      • Campus Connect
  • Language ›
    • Language
    • ‹ Back
      • English
      • Français
      • Español
      • Deutsch
      • Português
      • 简体中文
      • 日本語
  • Rapid Response from GEP
  • BLOGS
  • Strategy
  • Technology
  • MIND
Contact Us
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Breadcrumb

  1. HOME
  2. BLOG
  3. STRATEGY
  4. TURF WAR BETWEEN PROCUREMENT AND VENDOR MANAGEMENT
Blog Image

The Turf War Between Procurement and Vendor Management (And How to Resolve It)

  • When dealing with one another, procurement and vendor management teams often experience tension and mistrust
  • Is there a design decision framework they can use to improve the situation?
  • Fixing the operating model is the best way to minimize conflict. A 2x2 model shown in the blog can support mutual decision-making

February 25, 2022 | Procurement Strategy Blogs

If you’re a supply-side commercial professional and have worked for a mid-to-large-sized enterprise with a sizeable IT spend, you've most likely experienced the tension, the mistrust, and the turf war hidden behind masks of congeniality.

We are talking about the broken operating model between procurement teams and vendor management (VM) teams.

One can find this friction across organizations. Sometimes it’s a small issue’ sometimes a big issue, but never widely discussed. It’s often swept under the carpet and uneasy truces are formed to make-do.

Is there an operating model design decision framework you can use to improve the situation for procurement as well as vendor management?

But before we answer this question, let’s first take a detour to define strategic vendors and why procurement and VM teams do not see eye-to-eye.

The scope of VM is usually limited to strategic vendors.

Most large firms segment their supply base by criticality/spend (or both) and determine if the most critical/important suppliers require a vendor manager.

Strategic suppliers typically benefit (or suffer!) from a greater level of governance and strategic and operational interactions.

This gives them the opportunity to build closer relationships across the buying organization to understand the client needs better, and, theoretically, to have a greater opportunity to win more business and grow the account. The downside is typically greater exposure when things aren't working well and more administration in managing the account.

Strategic vendor management does not cover day-to-day order placement and issue resolution, purchase order placement and expediting. This is always going to require business ownership.

What is broken between procurement and vendor management?

Despite broadly having the same overarching aims -- to extract maximum value and protect their employers’ interests from the supply base -- there is significant mistrust between the two functions. The triangle diagram below represents a hypothesis that a lack of alignment between procurement and vendor management models means the goal of innovation is ineffectively exploited and represents a missed opportunity cost for business.

When vendor management is business-owned, operational effectiveness takes priority over other factors. Procurement can eye this suspiciously, viewing vendor management as tactical and day-to-day operational gophers. Surely, they are missing significant optimization opportunities as they are not commercial enough; not driven to change and improve like procurement?

On the other hand, when procurement muscles in on VM’s activities, the VM team eyes procurement defensively. This procurement crowd is willing to burn trust and relationships, burn bridges to save a dime.

They don't appreciate that you can’t RFP your way out of every situation and that there is give and take needed to make a contract work. And they don’t understand the intricacies of the business requirements because they swoop in and out sporadically, creating explosions that need repair.

Of course, these are caricatures and there would be beautiful procurement and VM relationships out there.

But do note the high level of skills overlap between the two groups. Many VM leaders and teams start life in procurement. Naturally, when a big commercial ask lands on a supplier, VM can feel well-equipped to deal with it without procurement. That lack of skills separation will naturally lead to a ‘treading-on-toes’ situation, which can add to the friction.

Closing the gap between procurement and VM through effective op model decisions

Fixing the operating model is the best way to minimize conflict, like this 2x2 model to support decision-making on which categories/ strategic suppliers should be managed where the key dimensions are:

(a) The level of alignment of interests between supplier and buyer

(b) The focus of commercial activity is either cost-efficiency or value-based

By mapping strategic suppliers to this model, you find four potential solution models for the relationship aspects:

1. Strategic Partner:

Here, both parties are co-developing their businesses, innovating, and developing offerings and are aligned on creating value. An example would be a bank’s relationship with partners such as Travelex or Western Union if they don't want to build that service in-house. Ownership here is typically held within the business, with procurement playing the supporting role.

2. Strategic Supplier:

Not requiring significant innovation but instead a job well done, large operational partners who service industry verticals would be examples of strategic suppliers. Proximity to the business is important but not critical. So, the determination of ownership in procurement will depend upon company-specific factors like individual staff know-how and relationship history.

3. Efficiency Supplier:

Here there is strong mutual alignment, but the emphasis is on removing waste from the supply chain to get things done more efficiently and safely. An example would be a 3/4 PL logistics provider. Ownership here would be suited to procurement leadership with support from the business.

4. Dependent Supplier:

This scenario would typically include many of the big SaaS and cloud platforms. Few organizations will individually have the scale to align strategically with the giants but they are critical to business operations. Again, a case-by-case review is needed to determine where relationships will have the biggest leverage. Typically, but not always with the chief information officer.

Other factors may need to be considered, including the number of business lines or stakeholders that use the supplier and whether one is a dominant user. Also, consider the appetite/willingness of the senior executive responsible toward delegating strategic aspects of the relationship.

Closing the gap through 'patches'

If the fix of an operating model re-design is too daunting, here are 5 tips to patch up the ways of working for the buyers and VM:

1. Joint leadership and communications between VM and procurement leaders:

Have the CPO and VM leaders share stages when communicating to their own teams and at supplier days.

2. Leverage 'top-to-top' relationships:

Use C-suite to C-suite connections to engender commitment from all parties and build energy.

3. Clarity on the RACI matrix for activities that involve VM:

Both Procurement and VM should have clear roles over the contract lifecycle. Should procurement join monthly, quarterly and monthly reviews? Who will be the point of escalation in the event of major incidents?

4. Team building between the two functions:

With shared leadership visionaries, trust-building and the operational level can be facilitated too.

5. Build strong communications loops on vendor performance and activities:

Whoever ends up owning the VM activity, there needs to be created clear and regular engagement paths to identify the current and future status of vendor performance.

Turn ideas into action. Talk to GEP.

GEP helps enterprise procurement and supply chain teams at hundreds of Fortune 500 and Global 2000 companies rapidly achieve more efficient, more effective operations, with greater reach, improved performance, and increased impact. To learn more about how we can help you, contact us today.

Graham Copeland
Senior Director- Business Development

Graham leads business development of the services organization for the UKI region. He has 25 years of procurement and sales leadership experience and has worked as an employee and a consultant with Schlumberger, Coop Group, Tesco Bank, BP, ABN Amro and Deutsche Bank. At GEP, he helps CPOs with operating model decisions and procurement transformations. He also runs the Proctopus procurement community. Graham holds a Bachelor’s degree in engineering and business from The University of Strathclyde.

LET'S TALK

 

Add Comment +

FEATURED POST

...
Supply Chain Strategy Blogs

How to Effectively Monitor Scope 3 Emissions From Your Supply Chain

...
Supply Chain Software Blogs

From Cost to Resiliency: How Supply Chain Priorities Have Changed

    BLOG CATEGORIES

  • Supply Chain Strategy Blogs
  • Procurement Strategy Blogs
  • Sourcing Strategy Blogs
  • Miscellaneous Blogs
  • Risk Management Blogs
  • Supplier Management Strategy Blogs
  • M&A Blogs
  • Supply Chain Risk Management Blogs
  • Cost Management Blogs
  • Digital Supply Chain Transformation Blogs
  • Inventory Management Blogs
  • Inventory Management

TAGS

sustainability
Procurement Software
supply chain strategy
Inflation
Russia-Ukraine War

By checking the box below, you consent to GEP using your personal information to send you thought leadership content – such as white papers, research reports, case studies – and other communications. GEP representatives may contact you to provide additional information or answer questions.

If at any point in time you decide to withdraw your consent, you may unsubscribe by emailing your request to us at privacy@gep.com.

Please refer to the GEP Privacy Statement to understand how we manage and protect your personal information.

Terms of Use | Privacy Statement

Contact Us

Ask Us

Send us your question(s)

RFP

Request for a business proposal

Feedback

Share your thoughts, comments and suggestions

Demo

Schedule a live demo of our software

Discover
STRATEGY
Strategy
  •   Procurement Consulting
  •   Digital Procurement Transformation
  •   Strategic Cost Management
  •   Opportunity Assessment
  •   Supply Chain Risk Management
  •   Supply Chain Consulting
  •   Supply Chain Strategy
  •   Supply Chain Diagnostics
  •   Inventory Optimization
  •   Procurement Transformation
  •   Sustainability and ESG Consulting
SOFTWARE
Software
  •   Procurement Software
  •   Supply Chain Software
  •   Source-to-Contract
  •   Procure-to-Pay
  •   Supply Chain Planning
  •   Supply Chain Collaboration
  •   Supply Chain Visibility & Execution
  •   Supply Chain Control Tower
  •   Should-Cost Modeling
  •   Inventory & Warehouse Management Software
  •   Source-To-Pay Software
MANAGED SERVICES
Managed Services
  •   Procurement Outsourcing
  •   Strategic Sourcing
  •   Tail-Spend Management
  •   Category Management
  •   Procurement Support Services
  •   Supply Chain Outsourcing
  •   Supply Chain Planning & Forecasting
  •   Inventory Management
  •   Logistics Management
COMPANY
Company
  •   About Us
  •   Leadership
  •   Customers
  •   Sustainability at GEP
  •   Careers
  •   News
  •   Awards
  •   Partners
  •   Contact Us

Fresh Insights, Now on Your Phone

  • Dowmload On The App Store Button
Stay Connected
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Latest Tweets

  • What steps can companies take to achieve #ESG goals effectively? Well, they can start with #procurement. Learn how… https://t.co/HGEfNyGdeD

  • #ElectricVehicles are a key part of the auto industry's plan to become #NetZero by 2050. But EVs aren't enough on t… https://t.co/YlEoys6vTA

  • Why did Asahi choose #GEP as their #procurement and #SupplyChain partner? Check out this video featuring Carmen Rad… https://t.co/RmstcfJXtm

  • GEPpers know how to have a good time! Check out a glimpse of our Winter Party at the GEP Prague office. We are hir… https://t.co/BqVK6XkpHv

  • #Inflation has dampened expectations for GDP growth and raised the risks of a #recession. What can #procurement lea… https://t.co/Hn1R5bxZXn

  • 4D seismic #technology is opening deep-sea #OilAndGas reserves for exploration, lowering costs and optimizing reser… https://t.co/Omq51vlEq7

  • The #GEP Europe Outlook 2023 Roadshow is coming to a city near you! Join us to learn the seven critical priorities… https://t.co/Hzv68et4Rr

  • GEP wishes a Happy Republic Day to all the Indians around the world.  We are #hiring. Explore our careers section:… https://t.co/RKTsyBfQFc

  • Sustainability Outlook for 2023: Trends, Insights and Actions 25 Jan 2023 https://t.co/58KIepy577

  • #Pharma companies are reshoring production, but shortages of active pharmaceutical ingredients make it a challenge.… https://t.co/a3uQJhn7tx

  • With uncertainty looming over 2023, there’s no end in sight to the challenges for #SupplyChain and #Procurement lea… https://t.co/O9tWELnt2i

  • Tight timelines and #COVID-related uncertainties made post-merger data ecosystem #convergence a tricky task for thi… https://t.co/RY6du0AP1D

  • Discover the keys to operating a strategic #procurement and supply function at an essential #PetroChemicals company… https://t.co/sJZmqhnWvS

  • What action should business leaders be taking on #sustainability in 2023? Join #GEP Founder and COO @JT_Turimella a… https://t.co/aerbJSp3GU

  • The pandemic and a labor shortage have exposed gaps in #pharma supply chains. Digital #SupplyChain transformation c… https://t.co/Bwvey5ObWn

  • GEP wishes everyone a very Happy Lunar New Year. May this Year of the Rabbit herald fresh starts and renewal of pro… https://t.co/Lnf3ZkO2zJ

  • Facing uncertainty and #disruption, #procurement needs agility — something #ERPs can’t provide. Here are 5 things t… https://t.co/ouGnhfW6wM

  • #GEP's Global Supply Chain Volatility Index reports 'Demand For Raw Materials Goes Down Reflecting Recession Risks'… https://t.co/dvIRfr8eyd

  • 2023 looks like another challenging year for #LifeSciences companies. This definitive #GEP outlook looks at the mac… https://t.co/ITzThy1PuC

© Copyright GEP 2022. All rights reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Statement | Cookie Policy |   | Quality Policy | GEP Logo