Skip to main content
  • login
  • contact
  • language
    • English
    • Français
    • Español
    • Português
    • Deutsch
    • Italia
    • 简体中文
    • 日本語
  • search
X
GEP Logo GEP Logo
  • Company
    • About Us
    • Leadership
    • Customers
    • Partners
    • AI-First at GEP
    • Sustainability at GEP
    • News
    • Events
    • Culture
    • Mission & Vision
    • Awards & Recognition
  • Solutions
    • Software
      • GEP SMART  
        • AI-First Source-to-Pay
        • Procurement Software
        • Product Accessibility
        • Direct Procurement Software
        • Indirect Procurement Software
        • Intelligent Category Management
        • Digital Procurement Transformation
        • Master Data Management
        • AP Automation
        • Spend Management
        • GEP COSTDRIVERS
      • Midsize & High Growth Enterprises  
      • GEP NEXXE  
        • AI-First Supply Chain Management
        • Supply Chain Visibility and Execution
        • Supply Chain Planning
        • Supply Chain Collaboration
        • Supply Chain Control Tower
        • Should-Cost Modeling
        • Inventory and Warehouse Management
        • Direct Material Sourcing
        • GEP Multienterprise Collaboration Network
      • GEP CLICK  
      • GEP MINERVA  
      • GEP BUILD  
      • GEP ASSIST  
      • GEP SPECTRUM XA  
      • GEP GREEN  
      Strategy
      • Procurement Consulting  
        • Procurement Transformation
        • Digital Procurement Transformation
        • Opportunity Assessment
        • M & A Services
        • Strategic Cost Management
        • Supply Risk Management
      • Supply Chain Consulting  
        • Environmental, Social and Governance
        • Socially Responsible Sourcing
        • Supply Chain Strategy
        • Supply Chain Diagnostics
        • Inventory Optimization
        • Network Optimization
        • GEP Total Inventory Management Solution
      Managed Services
      • Procurement Outsourcing  
        • Source-to-Contract
          • Spend Analysis
          • Strategic Sourcing
          • Category Management
          • Supply Market Intelligence
          • Tail-Spend Management
          • Procurement Support Services
        • Procure-to-Pay
          • Cost Recovery & Invoice Auditing
          • Accounts Payable
      • Supply Chain Outsourcing  
        • Planning & Forecasting
        • Inventory Management
        • Logistics Management
        • Supply Chain Data Management
        • Supply Chain Risk Management
  • Industries
    • Automotive
    • Chemicals
    • Consumer Packaged Goods
    • Energy & Utilities
    • Financial Services
    • Government & Nonprofit
    • Industrial Manufacturing
    • Life Sciences
    • Oil & Gas
    • Private Equity
    • Retail
    • Telecommunications, Media & Technology
    • High-Tech
    • Media & Entertainment
    • Software, Social & Platforms
    • Telecom
    • Travel & Hospitality
  • Knowledge Bank
    • Explore by Topic
      • Artificial Intelligence  
      • Digital Transformation  
      • Software & Technology  
      • Strategy & Planning  
      • Operations  
      • Procurement  
      • Sustainability  
      • Inflation Strategies  
      Explore by Type
      • White Papers  
      • Research Reports  
      • Bulletin  
      • Case Studies  
      • Webcasts  
      • Blogs  
      • Podcasts  
      • Insights From the Top  
      • Glossary  
      Global Supply Chain Volatility Index

      Latest Insight

      Navigating shifts Read More  

      Rethinking Supply Chains for Greater Efficiency, Resiliency, and Sustainability Read More  

  • Careers
    • Join Us
    • GEP Per Se
    • Campus Connect
  • Partners
   
  • GEP Software ›
    • GEP Software
    • ‹ Back
      • GEP SMART ›
        • GEP SMART
        • ‹ Back
          • AI-First Source-to-Pay
          • Procurement Software
          • Direct Procurement Software ›
            • Direct Procurement Software
            • ‹ Back
              • Bill of Materials Management
              • Data Analytics & Reporting
              • Inventory Management
              • Master Data Management
              • Quality Management
              • Supplier Collaboration Portal
              • Supply Chain Operations
          • Indirect Procurement Software ›
            • Indirect Procurement Software
            • ‹ Back
              • Source-to-Contract
              • Spend Analysis
              • Savings Project Management
              • Category Management
              • Contract Management
              • Savings Tracking
              • Sourcing
              • Supplier Management
              • Procure-to-Pay
              • Guided Buying
              • Procurement Portal
              • Catalog Management
              • Order Processing
              • Invoice Management
          • Intelligent Category Management
          • Digital Procurement Transformation
          • Spend Management
          • Master Data Management
          • AP Automation
          • Product Accessibility
          • GEP COSTDRIVERS
          • Midsize & High Growth Enterprises
      • GEP NEXXE ›
        • GEP NEXXE
        • ‹ Back
          • AI-First Supply Chain Management
          • Supply Chain Visibility and Execution ›
            • Supply Chain Visibility and Execution
            • ‹ Back
              • Inventory and Warehouse Management
              • Logistics Visibility
              • Control Tower
          • Supply Chain Planning ›
            • Supply Chain Planning
            • ‹ Back
              • Supply Chain Control Tower
              • Should-Cost Modeling
              • Demand Planning
              • Supply Chain Bill of Materials
              • Supply Chain Direct Sourcing
              • Supply Planning
          • Supply Chain Collaboration ›
            • Supply Chain Collaboration
            • ‹ Back
              • Forecast Collaboration
              • Purchase Order Collaboration
              • Quality Collaboration
              • Capacity Collaboration
              • Quality Management Software
          • Supply Chain Control Tower
          • Should-Cost Modeling
          • Inventory and Warehouse Management
          • GEP Multienterprise Collaboration Network
      • GEP CLICK
      • GEP MINERVA
      • GEP BUILD
      • GEP ASSIST
      • GEP SPECTRUM XA
      • GEP GREEN
      • Innovation ›
        • Innovation
        • ‹ Back
          • Emerging Technologies
          • Native to Cloud
          • Native to Mobile
          • One Unified Platform
          • Security
          • User-Centric Design
  • GEP Strategy ›
    • GEP Strategy
    • ‹ Back
      • Procurement Consulting ›
        • Procurement Consulting
        • ‹ Back
          • Procurement Transformation ›
            • Procurement Transformation
            • ‹ Back
              • Procurement Strategy
              • Org. Design & Implementation
              • Capability Building
              • Change Management
              • Governance & Performance
              • Processes & Policies
              • S2P Operations
              • Sourcing & Category Management
              • Technology
          • Digital Procurement Transformation
          • Opportunity Assessment
          • M&A Services ›
            • M&A Services
            • ‹ Back
              • M&A Clean Room
          • Strategic Cost Management ›
            • Strategic Cost Management
            • ‹ Back
              • Zero-Based Budgeting
          • Supply Chain Risk Management
      • Supply Chain Consulting ›
        • Supply Chain Consulting
        • ‹ Back
          • SUSTAINABILITY AND RESILIENCE
          • Environmental, Social and Governance
          • Socially Responsible Sourcing
          • Scope 3
          • PLAN
          • Digital Planning, S&OP, S&OE
          • Collaborative Planning
          • PROCURE
          • Source To Contract
          • Procure To Pay
          • MAKE
          • Inventory Strategy & Management
          • Operations & Manufacturing Excellence
          • GEP Total Inventory Management Solution
          • DELIVER
          • Network Strategy & Optimization
          • Warehousing & Transportation Management
  • GEP Managed Services ›
    • GEP Managed Services
    • ‹ Back
      • Procurement Outsourcing ›
        • Procurement Outsourcing
        • ‹ Back
          • Source-to-Contract
          • Spend Analysis
          • Strategic Sourcing ›
            • Strategic Sourcing
            • ‹ Back
              • MRO
              • CAPEX
              • Logistics
              • Packaging
              • IT & Telecom
              • Energy
              • Direct Materials
          • Category Management ›
            • Category Management
            • ‹ Back
              • Contract Management
              • Supplier Performance Management
              • Savings & Compliance Tracking
          • Supply Market Intelligence
          • Tail-Spend Management
          • Procurement Support Services ›
            • Procurement Support Services
            • ‹ Back
              • eSourcing
              • Supplier Performance Management
              • Savings & Compliance Tracking
              • Sourcing Support
          • Procure-to-Pay
          • Cost Recovery & Invoice Auditing
          • Accounts Payable
      • Supply Chain Outsourcing ›
        • Supply Chain Outsourcing
        • ‹ Back
          • Planning & Forecasting
          • Inventory Management
          • Logistics Management
          • Supply Chain Data Management
          • Supply Risk Management
  • Industries ›
    • Industries
    • ‹ Back
      • Automotive
      • Chemicals
      • Consumer Packaged Goods
      • Energy & Utilities
      • Financial Services
      • Government & Nonprofit
      • Industrial Manufacturing
      • Life Sciences
      • Oil & Gas
      • Private Equity
      • Retail
      • Telecommunications, Media & Technology
      • High-Tech
      • Media & Entertainment
      • Software, Social & Platforms
      • Telecom
      • Travel & Hospitality
  • Knowledge Bank ›
    • Knowledge Bank
    • ‹ Back
      • Explore by Topic ›
        • Explore by Topic
        • ‹ Back
          • Artificial Intelligence
          • Digital Transformation
          • Operations
          • Procurement
          • Software & Technology
          • Strategy & Planning
          • Sustainability
          • Inflation Strategies
      • Explore by Type ›
        • Explore by Type
        • ‹ Back
          • Insights From the Top
          • White Papers
          • Research Reports
          • Bulletins
          • Case Studies
          • Webcasts
          • Blogs
          • Podcasts
          • Glossary
      • Global Supply Chain Volatility Index
  • Company ›
    • Company
    • ‹ Back
      • About Us
      • Leadership
      • Customers
      • Partners
      • AI-First at GEP
      • Sustainability at GEP
      • News
      • Events
      • Culture ›
        • Culture
        • ‹ Back
          • GEP Core Values
          • Women@GEP
          • Diversity
          • GEP Cares
      • Mission & Vision
      • Awards & Recognition
      • Contact Us
  • Global Presence ›
    • Global Presence
    • ‹ Back
      • Americas ›
        • Americas
        • ‹ Back
          • English
          • Español
          • Portugués
      • Europe ›
        • Europe
        • ‹ Back
          • English
          • Deutsch
      • Asia-Pacific ›
        • Asia-Pacific
        • ‹ Back
          • English
          • 中文
      • Middle East ›
        • Middle East
        • ‹ Back
          • English
          • العربية
  • Contact Us
  • Careers ›
    • Careers
    • ‹ Back
      • GEP Per Se
      • Campus Connect
  • Language ›
    • Language
    • ‹ Back
      • English
      • Français
      • Español
      • Deutsch
      • Italia
      • Português
      • 简体中文
      • 日本語
  • BLOGS
  • Strategy
  • Technology
  • MIND
Contact Us
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Breadcrumb

  1. HOME
  2. BLOG
  3. STRATEGY
  4. IS THE KRALJIC MODEL OF PROCUREMENT BROKEN
Blog Image

Is the Kraljic Model of Procurement Broken?

  • The 2x2 model proposed in 1983 has become the de-facto strategic decision-making tool on how to manage supplier interactions.
  • Yet many procurement teams continue to misunderstand and misapply the model.
  • The sustainable procurement portfolio model proposed by Pagell et al. addressed many of the deficiencies in Kraljic but is not widely known.

April 10, 2023 | Procurement Strategy

It has been 40 years since management consultant Peter Kraljic published his seminal paper in the Harvard Business Review. Since then, the 2x2 Kraljic matrix or model has become the de-facto strategic decision-making tool on how to manage supplier interactions. The model has been a key contributor to turning procurement into a strategic business contributor.

How times have changed. On re-reading today, it refers to high technology using the example of a 256K RAM chip, for example! But also, the priorities and scope of category management has shifted, and the model is creaking under the weight of 2020s priorities.

Also read: How a New CPO Can Pick the Right Savings Transformation Flavor

Applying the Kraljic Model: A Mixed Report Card

The models in the paper have been widely misapplied and misunderstood.

  • Procurement teams mostly apply with some success "Phase 1: Classification" using the eponymous 2x2 matrix (Bottleneck, Leverage, etc.). The phase is criticized for being too subjective but it’s easy to apply and therefore widely disseminated. Subjectivity leads to a bias where category managers overstate the profit impact and risk dimensions in their analysis. After all, who wants to be managing non-strategic categories?
  • A large minority of teams do not apply "Phase 2: Market Analysis" which is a useful portfolio analysis matrix. It’s a well-known model (Nuisance, Exploit etc) but not always used.
  • Few procurement teams apply “Phase 3: Strategic Positioning," which is the final model on how to treat strategic suppliers.

Is It Time for a Change?

There have been many critiques of the Kraljic model, not the least Kraljic himself, who wished the concept of collaboration was more prominent in the paper.

It does not capture the concept of networks, the interdependencies between products or the concern for sustainability1.

Andrew Cox, professor emeritus of the International Institute for Advanced Purchasing & Supply, said that the Kraljic model "does not provide us with any proactive thinking about what can or should be done to change the existing reality of power.2"

Also read: Deciding When To Build or When To Buy a Procurement Function (Or Parts)

The Negative Impact of Decision-making Based on Kraljic

With the growing awareness of modern slavery in supply chains, it’s become clear that procurement actions matter. Applying too vigorously one approach based on Kraljic increases the risk of workforce exploitation as shown below.

workforce-exploitation

Leverage: Higher risk of labour exploitation if suppliers face negative margins

Non-Critical Items: Last-minute changes to orders or requirements equals higher risk of workers not getting paid

Bottleneck: Longer payment terms and extended order-to-payment lifecycle are shown to reduce weekly pay level

Strategic: Imposing well-meaning but typically western solutions and values through various policies and directives may actually damage the workers and their families overall income.

So over-zealous application of Kraljic could cause harm. And furthermore, something started to show up in research. Was Kraljic becoming broken?

"During the analysis of data collected as part of a study on exemplars in Strategic Supply Chain Management (SSCM), a significant anomaly emerged related to the well-established purchasing portfolio framework. We observed that a number of leaders in SSCM were not making purchasing decisions in the manner suggested by Kraljic (1983) nor were these firms acting in ways that alternative approaches would completely predict, 3" says a paper by Mark Pagell, Zhaohui Wu and Michael E. Wasserman.

The main revelation is that buying firms are not leveraging their commodity purchases in particular circumstances. These include business continuity and sustainability risks.

Instead, benevolent suppliers are seeking common prosperity with some suppliers in the hope of improving long-term market conditions to help lift employees out of impoverishment and improve the environmental impact of its supply base on the local communities it works in.

In short, the Kraljic model no longer works in the 'Leverage' quadrant in commodity markets that are environmental or social risk. These leverage commodities need to be treated as strategic when the triple bottom line impact is threatened.

Pagell et al. therefore have proposed a variant of Kraljic.

Strategic-Commodities

The key variations are:

1. The Y-axis is sensibly expanded to become "Threat to Triple Bottom Line"

2. The removal of leverage items into three commodity types:

  • (a) True commodities that are treated as per the Kraljic model leverage definitions
  • (b) Strategic Commodities are those critical commodities that transcend traditional economic considerations. For example, energy, primary raw materials for an energy firm, food ingredients for a food manufacturer etc.
  • (c) Transitional Commodities that may receive temporary status as 'strategic' in order to raise overall standards, well-being and sustainability goals before returning to a more traditional True Commodity status when supply market standards confidently meet the buyer goals.

Whilst this revised model by Pagell et al. was released in 2009, and is widely cited by scholars, it remains relatively unknown amongst practitioners.

This paper, now 15 years old, was ahead of its time, but now, with significant sustainability commitments mandated or committed to by organizations, it’s time to think again and harder about our flawed modeling of purchasing and supply dynamics.

“An attitude of ‘purchasing as usual’ will make the company vulnerable to competitive pressure; but enhanced strategic awareness, greater flexibility, and stronger entrepreneurial thinking in the supply area can improve the supply security and lower the input costs of any company.”

Krajlic had closed his HBR paper4 with these words as a clarion call to action. They still ring true 40 years later.

Author: Graham Copeland


1 [1] Geldeman & Weele, Purchasing Portfolio Models: A Critique and Update, Literature Review, 2005

2 Cox, A. Business Success — A Way of Thin king about Strategic, Critical Supply Chain Assets and Operational Best Practice, Earlsgate Press, Great Britain, 1997

3 Pagell, M et al. "Thinking Differently About Purchasing Portfolios: An Assessment Of Sustainable Sourcing", Journal of Supply Management, 2009

4 Peter Kraljic, “Purchasing Must Become Supply Management”, Harvard Business Review, 1983

 

Tags: Procurement , Procurement Strategy

Add Comment +

FEATURED POST

...
Inventory Management Software

Achieving Supply Chain Resilience With Total Inventory Management Solution

...
Supply Chain Strategy

Sodium-ion vs. Lithium-ion Battery: Which is a Better Alternative?

...
Supply Chain Strategy

3 Best Practices to Tackle Inflation in Supply Chain Network Design

    BLOG CATEGORIES

  • Supply Chain Strategy
  • Procurement Strategy
  • Sourcing Strategy
  • Risk Management
  • Miscellaneous
  • Supplier Management Strategy
  • M&A
  • Cost Management
  • Supply Chain Risk Management
  • Inventory Management
  • Digital Supply Chain Transformation

TAGS

sustainability
Procurement Software
supply chain strategy
Inflation
Russia-Ukraine War

By checking the box below, you consent to GEP using your personal information to send you thought leadership content – such as white papers, research reports, case studies – and other communications. GEP representatives may contact you to provide additional information or answer questions.

If at any point in time you decide to withdraw your consent, you may unsubscribe by emailing your request to us at privacy@gep.com.

Please refer to the GEP Privacy Statement to understand how we manage and protect your personal information.

Terms of Use | Privacy Statement

Contact Us

Ask Us

Send us your question(s)

RFP

Request for a business proposal

Feedback

Share your thoughts, comments and suggestions

Demo

Schedule a live demo of our software

Discover
STRATEGY
Strategy
  •   Procurement Consulting
  •   Digital Procurement Transformation
  •   Strategic Cost Management
  •   Opportunity Assessment
  •   Supply Chain Risk Management
  •   Supply Chain Consulting
  •   Supply Chain Strategy
  •   Supply Chain Diagnostics
  •   Inventory Optimization
  •   Procurement Transformation
  •   Sustainability and ESG Consulting
SOFTWARE
Software
  •   Procurement Software
  •   Supply Chain Software
  •   Source-to-Contract
  •   Procure-to-Pay
  •   Supply Chain Planning
  •   Supply Chain Collaboration
  •   Supply Chain Visibility & Execution
  •   Supply Chain Control Tower
  •   Should-Cost Modeling
  •   Inventory & Warehouse Management Software
  •   Source-To-Pay Software
  •   Midsize & High Growth Enterprises
MANAGED SERVICES
Managed Services
  •   Procurement Outsourcing
  •   Strategic Sourcing
  •   Tail-Spend Management
  •   Category Management
  •   Procurement Support Services
  •   Supply Chain Outsourcing
  •   Supply Chain Planning & Forecasting
  •   Inventory Management
  •   Logistics Management
COMPANY
Company
  •   About Us
  •   Leadership
  •   Customers
  •   Sustainability at GEP
  •   Careers
  •   News
  •   Awards
  •   Partners
  •   Contact Us

Fresh Insights, Now on Your Phone

  • GoGEP app on Apple App Store
  • GoGEP app on Google Play Store
Stay Connected
  •  
  •  
  •  

Latest Tweets

© Copyright GEP 2023. All rights reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Statement | Cookie Policy |   | Quality Policy | GEP Logo